mhafan15 toby because it's toby

Khlobear11 My favorite creepypasta character is Jeff The Killer because he’s such a beautiful, beautiful man

Slasherfan27 Mine is Jason the Toymaker, Sally, Toby, Splendorman, and BEN Drowned.

raining_angel Mines Toby cause he can’t feel pain and I feel bad for him and Ben cause he could kick your ass in a game and in real life and sally cause I would have helped her kill her uncle Johnny